Tag Archives: Detroit Tigers

Weekly Hit Ground Ball: Dizzying deadline day

WHGB11It’s the nature of most things these days that they are hyped to the moon. Promising something good isn’t good enough. It has to be the biggest, the best, the most controversial or outrageous to be worthy of anyone’s attention, apparently.

All of which leaves any sane person viewing any ‘big event’ with a healthy dose of scepticism. If you’re guaranteed excitement and drama, the chances are it will not live up to the billing; you might as well accept it to begin with and not get sucked in by the hype.

And yet every now and then that scepticism proves to be misplaced. The drama foretold really does unfold.

That’s exactly what we enjoyed last Thursday evening from the MLB trade deadline.

The British football transfer deadline is, ‘thanks’ to Sky Sport News, a ridiculous farce in which every minor potential deal is talked about as a major news story. ASBOs in waiting crowd around a gormless reporter at a dark training ground and get excited about a distinctly average player signing for an inflated fee who will soon become forgettable. Still, for that fleeting moment he gives the team the feeling that they are at least doing something and that’s all the matters.

It is still exciting if your team does happen to land a player who will genuinely improve the team, but there’s a lingering thought that most of the players couldn’t care who they play for anyway. The majority of transfers are characterised – fairly or not – by a player forcing his way out of the club, demanding his contract to be paid up in full alongside a loyalty bonus so that he can get a signing-on fee and a bigger salary at another team.

Nothing summed it up better than the sight of striker Peter Odemwingie sat in his car outside Loftus Road having driven himself to the club he wanted to join despite his present team, West Brom at the time, not having actually agreed to sell him. In that case ‘player power’ didn’t rule the day: Odemwingie’s move fell through and he was left looking like a prat and condemned forever more as the butt of many a joke.

In complete contrast, most trades in MLB happen without a player’s say-so. Austin Jackson was merrily standing in centrefield at Comerica Park on Thursday playing for the Detroit Tigers, the team he’s been with since the start of 2010, before he was called off the field mid-game and told he had been traded to the Seattle Mariners.

There was nothing he could say or do other than hug his team mates and start to pack his bags.

Asdrubal Cabrera was at Progressive Field, the place he’s called home since 2007, looking ahead to his team’s game against the Seattle Mariners when he found out that he wouldn’t be donning the Cleveland uniform that day after all. Instead, he sat on his own in the concourses outside the clubhouse and quietly took in the news that he would be moving to Washington.

That photo sums the emotions up well. Cabrera is moving to the current NL East division leaders and so it’s a good opportunity for him – rather than being traded away to a cellar-dweller as can sometimes happen – yet that doesn’t soften the initial blow of leaving behind the people and places you’ve become so accustomed to being part of your daily life.

Before we feel to guilty about taking such pleasure in players being cast hither and tither, they are of course doing what they love and getting paid very handsomely for the privilege.

In fact, it’s sometimes the amount that they are getting paid – or soon will be upon signing a free agent contract – that leads to a team trading them away.

Jon Lester’s preference clearly was to be a lifelong Red Sox player, yet he was unable to come to agreement with the team on a contract extension so he was traded to the Oakland A’s in the first shot of a thrilling deadline day of dealing. Both Lester and Boston have stated that their separation may not be forever and that they could still be reunited this offseason when he becomes a free agent; however you have to assume that if Boston couldn’t find a figure they liked when negotiating exclusively with the pitcher, they’re even less likely to once other suitors get involved.

There was even less chance of David Price staying with the team that drafted him and for whom he’s played his entire career so far. The Tampa Bay Rays probably couldn’t even afford his 2015 salary in his final year before free agency, so he was dealt in a three-team trade to the Detroit Tigers (the Seattle Mariners being the other team involved). The Tigers are not exactly shy at spending big on players, although as with Boston and Lester they were unable to agree a contract extension over the past off-season with Max Scherzer.

Acquiring Price will make it easier to part ways with Scherzer this offseason, both in having a ready-made replacement for 2015 and giving them another opportunity to sign an ace-level pitcher to a multi-year contract.

Seeing where Lester and Scherzer end up over the offseason, and if the Tigers can reach a deal with Price, will be fascinating, but the free agent market will struggle to match up to this past trade deadline.

Waiver deals

And don’t forget that the trade deadline is only a partial deadline, as deals can still be completed, just not in such a straightforward one-on-one team negotiation process. MLB Trade Rumors explains the process well here.

Offseason so far: AL Central

After taking a look at the comings and goings in the American League East division yesterday, we move on to the AL Central.

Detroit Tigers

So near and yet so far, the Tigers reflected on a losing World Series appearance in 2012 and a losing American League Championship Series in 2013 and had to work out whether a small tweak or two would be enough to keep them in with a shot, or if a bold move was needed to get over the hump and win a World Series.

They’ve taken the latter approach. Veteran manager Jim Leyland has retired and in his place Detroit have chosen a new direction with rookie manager Brad Ausmus. That was a brave move, as was the decision to trade away first baseman Prince Fielder just two years into his blockbuster nine-year contract. Fielder has joined the Texas Rangers with Ian Kinsler – typically a second baseman, although he may move to the outfield in Detroit – going the other way.

Pitcher Doug Fister has also departed in a trade with the Washington Nationals, which wasn’t a surprise in itself considering Detroit have some excellent options already for their starting rotation, although the meagre return (primarily utility man Steve Lombardozzi) did leave many scratching their heads. Omar Infante (Royals) and Jhonny Peralta (Cardinals) have also found new teams as free agents.

As for incomings, Joe Nathan will fill the void as the team’s closer with Joba Chamberlain and Ian Krol also being added to the relief corps, whilst Rajai Davis should provide a speedy option from the bench.

Cleveland Indians

The Indians were one of the surprise teams of 2013, not just in making the playoffs but also in the way they went out over the previous offseason and added leading free agents Nick Swisher and Michael Bourn. The pair represented something of a splurge for the cash-strapped team and so they are making more modest investments this time around, primarily in the form of ex-Rangers outfielder David Murphy and reliever John Axford.

Cleveland’s rise to a playoff appearance once greatly helped by the pitching performances of Scott Kazmir and Ubaldo Jimenez, both of whom are free agents this offseason. Kazmir has already found a new club in the Oakland A’s, but Jimenez is still on the market and there does seem to be some hope that a deal could be agreed for him to return to the Indians. Meanwhile right-handed reliever Joe Smith has left the club as a free agent and signed with the Los Angeles Angels.

Kansas City Royals

The Royals made a splash a year ago by trading top prospect Wil Myers for pitchers James Shields and Wade Davis. Shields has just one more left on his contract before he becomes a free agent and whilst the team did jump from 72 wins in 2012 to 86 in 2013, that wasn’t a big enough leap to earn the postseason appearance that the team arguably needs to feel like trading such a talented young player as Myers was worth it.

So far this offseason, the Royals have added former Angels’ starting pitcher Jason Vargas and ex-Tiger Omar Infante on four-year contracts and also pulled off what could turn out to be a nifty trade by acquiring outfielder Norichika Aoki for pitcher Will Smith. They were close to bringing back Carlos Beltran to KC nine and half years after they traded him to the Astros, before the Yankees jumped in at the last moment and beat their bid. Pitcher Ervin Santana had a good season for the Royals last year and, as with Jimenez and Cleveland, the fact that he hasn’t yet found a match on the free agent market leaves open the possibility that he could still rejoin the team.

Minnesota Twins

Joe Mauer will not be catching in Minnesota in 2014 but that doesn’t mean the hometown hero has been taken away from the Twins. The 2009 AL MVP winner is ditching the ‘tools of ignorance’ and will give his body a rest while playing first base instead from this season onwards. Kurt Suzuki has been brought in to provide some experience at the catching position whilst prospect Josmil Pinto continues to develop (probably starting the season at Triple-A and earning a promotion mid-season). The Twins’ roster planning will also be mindful of the impending promotion of the exciting third baseman Miguel Sano.

The main development, aside from Mauer changing gloves, has come in the form of three free agent additions to the starting rotation. Ricky Nolasco, Phil Hughes and Mike Pelfrey have been brought in to revamp the pitching staff and it’s rumoured that they may also be joined by Bronson Arroyo in the near future.

Chicago White Sox

The White Sox suffered a dreadful 99-loss season in 2013 and one offseason isn’t going to be enough to turn that around. In fact, the south-siders have been open about cutting payroll in 2014 and trying to inject some young talent back into the organization.

However, they have made a couple of promising signings that could provide reason for cheer in the coming season. The most notable came in beating off a lot of competition to win the signature of Cuban slugger Jose Abreu. The 6-year, $68m contract is the most lucrative signed by an international free agent so far and reflects the fact that he is not merely someone with potential, but a 26-year-old slugger heading into what should be the prime of his career,

The White Sox joined with the Arizona Diamondbacks and the L.A. Angels to complete a three-team trade that resulted in Chicago gaining all-action outfielder Adam Eaton. He’ll join a White Sox lineup that will once again, and quite probably for the last year, feature Paul Konerko. The Chicago favourite had considered retirement but was tempted back for another season, albeit on the basis that he’ll be used as a part-time player.

Rounding the Bases: Deals completed with more on the way

The New York Yankees may have been leading the way, but there were plenty of other MLB teams making moves last week.

Seattle stunner

No one made a more impressive statement of intent than the Seattle Mariners. The 10-year, $240m contract agreed with Robinson Cano is the joint-third highest in MLB history, matching the contract the Los Angeles Angels agreed with Albert Pujols two offseasons ago and only trailing the Alex Rodriguez contracts of $252m and $275m.

Although they’ve been down on their luck in recent seasons, the Mariners are not a small market team and so the fact that they believe they can afford such a lucrative contract should not be shocking. The element of surprise came in part through them outbidding the Yankees and in part by the timing. Even adding a great player like Cano leaves them with an underwhelming batting lineup to go alongside an admittedly impressive 1-2 starting pitching punch of Felix Hernandez and Hisashi Iwakuma. Why invest so much money in Cano if there isn’t the talent around him to win?

Well, the simple answer is that if you want to improve, adding one of the best players in baseball is a good way to start. The Mariners are now being linked with a host of other names – including a potential trade for the Rays’ David Price – and whilst money certainly talks loudest when free agents decide on their new home (and understandably so), players do want to win too and Cano will be a very handy selling point to show that they are serious about being contenders.

The other point to note is that this is a multi-year commitment, not a one-year rental. Of course the Mariners will want to make the playoffs in 2014 and they’ll attract some criticism if they don’t, but it will be far from disastrous if 2014 sees the Mariners take a positive step forward to then set up an offseason recruitment exercise in a year’s time to make them genuine contenders.

And finally it’s worth learning a lesson from the recent trade of Prince Fielder to remind us all that nothing is ever as certain as it may seem. The Cano contract is a monumental commitment by the Mariners, but it’s quite possible (maybe even probable) that he will not be a Seattle player for that entire period. If one of the biggest risks is that he won’t be worth the money in the last few years of the contract – and it is – well, the chances are the Mariners might only be on the hook for a percentage of that salary while he plays for someone else anyway.

The Mariners need some more pieces to give themselves any chance of a playoff push in 2014; however it looks like they’re trying to add them and, even if they don’t, Seattle fans have every reason to be excited about what the coming years may bring.

A’s add several pieces

The Oakland A’s are two-time reigning AL West champions but it’s their lot to continue to go under the radar and be overshadowed by their rivals. Whilst they haven’t signed Robinson Cano or traded for Prince Fielder, the A’s were the most active team of the week and made a series of moves that should all prove beneficial in their quest to make it three division titles in a row.

Bartolo Colon and Grant Balfour are set to leave the A’s as free agents, so General Manager Billy Beane filled those holes with the signing of free agent Scott ‘comeback kid’ Kazmir and trading for the Baltimore Orioles’ closer Jim Johnson. Reliever Luke Gregerson (from the Padres) and outfielder Craig Gentry (from the Rangers) were also acquired in trades.

Red Sox rally from Ellsbury departure

In the AL East, the Boston Red Sox are doing a good job of hiding any disappointment they have in losing Jacoby Ellsbury to those damn Yankees. They’ve agreed a two-year deal to bring back Mike Napoli, added former Cardinal Edward Mujica to their bullpen and replaced the departed Jarrod Saltalamacchia (who’s signed for the Marlins) with veteran catcher A.J. Pierzynski, who will be keen to bounce back from a relatively disappointing one-year stay in Texas.

Nathan in, Fister out

The Detroit Tigers, the Red Sox’s 2013 American League Championship Series opponents, have ensured there will be no repeat of the closer confusion of last season as they signed Joe Nathan on a two-year contract. Meanwhile Doug Fister has been traded away to the Washington Nationals, possibly in part to clear some space on the payroll for Nathan.

The Tigers do have Drew Smyly as a ready-made replacement in the rotation, but it’s surprising that they didn’t get more of a return (utility player Steve Lombardozzi being the main player of three acquired) for a solid starter, one that the Nationals will be more than happy to have on their pitching staff in 2014. The Nationals made another move last week too, adding outfielder Nate McLouth.

Wilson returns

Brian Wilson was the other main closer candidate being considered by the Tigers. After Detroit opted for Nathan, Wilson decided to return to the L.A. Dodgers in a set-up role behind Kenley Jansen. That’s certainly not going to be the last move made by the Dodgers and much of their offseason plans may revolve around whether the rumours come true and they trade away either Andre Ethier or Matt Kemp.

Grandy stays in New York

Outfielder Curtis Granderson wasn’t in the Yankees’ grand spending plans this offseason but he will stay in New York regardless after signing a four-year deal with the Mets. Former Oakland A Chris Young had previously signed a one-year deal with the Mets as they seek to upgrade their outfield and start the process of getting back into contention in the NL East.

And that’s just for starters!

Last week’s transaction news may just be the first course in a baseball feast. This week the great and good of the baseball world will gather at the annual Winter Meetings, where rumours go into overdrive and, occasionally, major trades and free agent signings are agreed. If we’ve learned anything over the past seven days it’s that we should be prepared for a shock or two.

 

Rounding the Bases: Deals being made

One week ago I stated that we may be waiting a few weeks before the MLB Hot Stove started to heat up and teams began making significant roster additions.

It turned out that this past week was in fact quite a busy one, with several free agent signings being completed and one major trade.

Fielder and Kinsler swap teams

At breakfast time on Thursday morning I was tucking into a bowl of porridge and enjoying watching the highlights of Day One of the first Ashes Test on Sky Sports News (enjoy the good times while they last, comes to mind) when I noticed that an MLB news item was about to scroll across the bottom of the screen. I expected it to be news of a minor free agent signing, but instead was taken aback to read that the Texas Rangers had swung a trade to acquire first baseman Prince Fielder from the Detroit Tigers for second baseman Ian Kinsler.

Just two years ago, the Tigers caused a major shock by coming out of nowhere and signing Fielder to a nine-year, $214m contract. Despite having a disappointing 2013 season, Fielder appeared to be set to stay in Detroit for years to come and yet all of a sudden the long-term commitment between player and team had been broken.

At first glance it looks to be a trade that should benefit both teams handsomely, not just in the player each team has required but the knock-on effects for their respective rosters.

The Tigers can now move Miguel Cabrera over to first base, where his limited fielding skills are better suited, and create an opening for their best prospect, third baseman Nick Castellanos. Kinsler will add a combination of some power and speed to the lineup and moving the majority of Fielder’s hefty contract (the Tigers have given the Rangers $30m as part of the deal to cover some of the remaining $168m) gives them some financial flexibility potentially to add another player or two or to add to the pot for a contract extension for Max Scherzer and, down the line, Miguel Cabrera.

As for the Rangers, they were desperate to make a big move after suffering late season heartbreak in the last two seasons. Acquiring a premium slugger is a statement of intent and moving to the homer-friendly confines of Rangers Ballpark should suit Fielder down to the ground. Moving Kinsler also frees up some space for the Rangers to let top prospect Jurickson Profar settle in at second base.

Angels and Cardinals

The Rangers’ AL West rivals the Los Angeles Angels also completed a trade this week, acquiring third baseman David Freese from the St. Louis Cardinals for centre fielder Peter Bourjos, with a couple of young prospects thrown into the deal too.

Freese will forever be a hometown hero in St. Louis for his 2011 World Series heroics, yet it looks like a good time for him to move on to a new challenge with the Angels. The Cardinals will probably move their infield players around so that Matt Carpenter shifts over to third base and Kolten Wong moves into second base full-time, potentially with former Detroit Tiger Jhonny Peralta joining the team as their new shortstop if the rumours from Saturday night are accurate. Bourjos, if he can stay fit and on the field, will be a better option in centrefield than the disappointing John Jay for the Cards, whilst Mike Trout will no longer be moved aside to the Angels’ left field and will instead be the number one centre fielder.

Pitchers getting paid

David Freese should be a good addition for the Angels, but their most pressing need over the offseason is to bolster their pitching corps. Another opening in the rotation has been created by Jason Vargas departing as a free agent as he agreed a four-year, $32m contract with the Kansas City Royals.

The signing was met by a fairly lukewarm response. In part this was because of the Royals rumours swirling in the hour before it was announced:

A “major-baseball announcement” immediately created visions for some of Carlos Beltran donning the ‘KC’ cap once again, so when the reality was a player you can neatly file under the words ‘solid’ and ‘dependable’ there was bound to be some disappointment.

Giving a four-year contract to a less-than-spectacular player also raised a few eyebrows, yet $8m per year for a good starting pitcher looks like being a good deal for the Royals on the current pitching market.

The San Francisco Giants spent $23m this week to sign 38-year old Tim Hudson on a two-year contract (£137k per week). Hudson’s 2013 season was ended by a horrible freak accident when the Mets’ Eric Young accidentally landed on the pitcher’s right ankle as he was covering first base. The Giants are confident that Hudson will come back from his fractured ankle as good as new and if he does then he should help the team in their attempt to get back to the postseason and to win a third World Series in five years.

Elsewhere in the NL West, the San Diego Padres have also signed a pitcher whose 2013 was impacted by injury. Josh Johnson has spent most of his career so far battling the tag of being an ace when not injured. Recently he’s spent more time injured than being an ace but the Padres have little to lose in signing him to a one-year contract worth $8m and, with Petco Park being a great place for a pitcher to ply his trade, it’s also a good setting for Johnson to have a good year and then earn a more lucrative contract in a year’s time.

Another veteran for the Phillies

The Philadelphia Phillies played at the Veterans Stadium for 33 seasons before moving to Citizens Bank Park in 2004. The team’s General Manager Ruben Amaro Jr has done a good job in recent years of honouring their old home by building rosters dominated by veterans and, just a week after signing 36-year-old Marlon Byrd to a two-year contract, he added another this week with the re-signing of catcher Carlos Ruiz.

Ruiz has spent his whole Major League career with the Phillies and even when his contract ran out at the end of the 2013 season, there always seemed a very good chance that he would carry on with the club.

Amaro’s decision to hand the 35-year-old a three-year contract worth a guaranteed $26m (annual salaries of $8.5m – approximately £101k per week – with a $500k 2017 buyout fee) made sure of that and immediately led to the GM’s thought processes (or more precisely lack of) being questioned.

Giving a three-year contract to a 35-year-old catcher isn’t ideal, but Ruiz is a good all-round player, not spectacular at anything but solid enough at the plate and behind it, at a position where merely being good carries plenty of value. Additionally the risk involved is mitigated slightly by the Phillies’ familiarity with him, from how he fits into the group as a personality to a detailed knowledge of his fitness.

And finally …

The Phillies kept hold of their catcher, but it looks like the Atlanta Braves have lost theirs. Brian McCann has been with the Braves for his entire professional career and his nine-season Major League run with the team always looked likely to come to an end this offseason when he became a free agent. Sure enough, late on Saturday night it was being reported that he has agreed a five-year, $85m contract (just over £200k per week) with the New York Yankees.

Changing of the Old Guard

The videos and photos from Boston’s World Series parade tell us all that the sad moment has come around again: the baseball season is over and there are going to be no Major League games to enjoy for several months.

Of course, the baseball off-season is really the baseball-playing off-season. November to February will not be light on baseball news to devour, digest and comment upon; far from it.

The player ‘hot stove’ will likely take a few weeks to really start to simmer, but the managerial merry-go-round is already in full swing.

The main baseball story to read about on Sunday morning was the reports that the Detroit Tigers are going to appoint Brad Ausmus as their new manager, taking over from the retiring Jim Leyland.

If the reports are accurate, there’s going to be a significant change in direction in Detroit as, on the face of it, the Tigers are moving from one end of the spectrum to the other.

Leyland was the personification of ‘old school’ among Major League managers, 68 years old with 22 years of Major League managerial experience and plenty of worry lines on his face to prove it. In contrast, Ausmus is 44, only a few years removed from ending his Major League playing career in 2010 and, aside from a brief stint as Israel’s World Baseball Classic manager, possesses precisely zero managing or coaching experience at the Big League level.

Ausmus hasn’t paid his managerial or coaching dues, but does that really matter? With 18 years of Major League playing experience as a catcher, it’s very questionable whether a few years of managing in the Minors or being a third-base coach would significantly improve his ability to manage a Major League team.

No two individuals are exactly the same and the path required to prepare oneself for managing will differ accordingly.

Leyland, for example, never made it to the Majors as a player. He played in the Minors for seven seasons and then spent ten years as a Minor League manager before joining Tony La Russa’s staff as a third-base coach with the Chicago White Sox. That combined experienced led him to his first Major League managerial appointment with the Pittsburgh Pirates in 1986. Ausmus was drafted by the New York Yankees out of High School the following year.

The initial response to reports of Ausmus’s appointment has been extremely positive, lauding him as an intelligent baseball man with all the communication skills required to get the best out of his players. It will take some adjustment on behalf of those players though as they were familiar with Leyland’s ways and routines.

There’s no doubt that it’s a great job for Ausmus to take on considering the playing talent he has at his disposal. That creates a certain amount of pressure as if things don’t go so well then fingers will be pointed at the new link in the chain and his lack of managerial and coaching experience will then be a talking point.

Walt Weiss took over the Colorado Rockies prior to the 2013 season and like Ausmus he came into it with only his Major League playing career to fall back on. The Rockies subsequently finished dead last in the NL West with a 74-88 record but no one saw that as a reflection on Weiss. Rightfully there were low expectations going into the season due to the playing roster he had to work with and Weiss was able to use the year as a learning experience.

However, given the choice of getting your feet wet in relative comfort with a team not expected to be in contention or diving straight in with a team that has reached two ALCS’s and a World Series in the last three season, anyone would gladly accept the pressure that Ausmus will be under in 2014. Fellow ex-catcher Mike Matheny will testify to that having completed the same leap as Ausmus in replacing Leyland’s old friend La Russa in St. Louis two seasons ago.

If Ausmus is confirmed in post with the Tigers, that will leave two Major League managerial vacancies still to be filled at the Chicago Cubs and Seattle Mariners respectively.

So far this offseason, the Washington Nationals have chosen former Arizona Diamondbacks third-base coach Matt Williams to replace the retiring Davey Johnson, whilst the Cincinnati Reds promoted pitching coach Bryan Price to take over from the sacked Dusty Baker.

When you add in Ryne Sandberg being confirmed as the full-time successor to Charlie Manuel after serving as the interim manger with the Philadelphia Phillies, there’s a real changing of the old guard taking place among the ranks of Major League managers. It will be interesting to see if the Cubs and Mariners follow this pattern with their appointments over the next few weeks.

Further reading

Full details of Jim Leyland’s playing and managerial career can be found on his Baseball-Reference page.

No more Neighbourhood plays?

Wednesday’s games in the MLB postseason left both the American and National League Championship Series finely poised.

The Los Angeles Dodgers’ survived their first ‘must-win’ game, denying – temporarily perhaps – the St. Louis Cardinals a berth in the World Series with a 6-4 victory. The series will now head back to St. Louis for Game Six on Friday night.

Whilst the Cardinals remain favourites leading the series 3-2, a win for the Dodgers in Game Six will not only level the series, it will also bring back all the bad memories the Cardinals have of letting a 3-1 NLCS lead slip last year against the San Francisco Giants.

In the ALCS, the Boston Red Sox and Detroit Tigers will play Game Five on Thursday night with all to play for. The Tigers took Game Four 7-3 to make the series all square at two apiece.

Detroit jumped on Red Sox starter Jake Peavy, scoring five runs in the second inning. Boston had a chance to escape a bases-loaded situation having conceded only one run, but Dustin Pedroia and Stephen Drew were unable to turn an inning-ending double-play and despite a late rally, they were never able to recover.

Watching that inning again on Thursday evening, the main thing that stood out was that the Red Sox were lucky to get even one out on the potential double-play. Second base umpire Dan Iassogna called Austin Jackson out on a force play even though Drew hadn’t touched the bag, nor got particularly close to doing so.

It has long been the case that umpires have given fielders some leeway at second base when base runners are charging in trying to break up a double-play. The pivot man on the play, in this case the shortstop Drew, is vulnerable to being caught unguarded by what amounts to a sliding tackle.

So long as the fielder is ‘in the neighbourhood’ of the base, he will be given the out. It’s the baseball equivalent of a referee whistling for a foul when a defender slides in and doesn’t actually make heavy contact with the attacker. The fouled player shouldn’t have to leave his leg in the way and get it broken to prove that it was a mis-timed dangerous tackle, and a pivot man on a double-play shouldn’t have to suffer such an injury either.

However, what will happen next season when instant replay is introduced?

Maybe there will be a gentleman’s agreement that managers will not challenge such a play, knowing that allowing it as a general rule helps protect the players.

No,  I don’t see that lasting too long either when an important game is on the line and, in any case, the incident in last night’s game shows there’s a significant grey area involved. Whether someone tags a bag or not is clear enough. Whether a fielder is ‘in the neighbourhood’ of the base is much more subjective. Certainly Tigers manager Jim Leyland would have been well within his rights to challenge the call in this case yet one person’s definition of close will differ from another, largely based on which team you are attached to.

What’s more likely to happen is that players simply will have to adjust and make sure they touch the base, taking the ‘neighbourhood play’ out of the equation. I’ve stated before that introducing instant replay doesn’t just involve adding a new officiating tool, it will also change the way the game is played.

In this case, the result also could be an increase in injuries to infielders and if that happens they’ll potentially be a clamour for a rule change or two. One possibility would be for umpires to take a hard line on calling interference on a baserunner going into second base if the pivot man would in any way be likely to be touched in attempting to turn the double-play. Traditionalists will like that as much as they like the idea of collisions at home plate being outlawed.

It could have a series of consequences, or maybe everyone will quickly adjust and it doesn’t become an issue. It’s difficult to tell, yet it’s clear that instant replay will change baseball. Whether that’s for better or worse remains to be seen and like every other issue in baseball, opinions will be divided.

Baseball, like all sports, will continue to evolve and the game in MLB will be different as a result of instant replay.

 

 

Championship Series thoughts on a rainy Sunday

For many in the U.K., today is the sort of Sunday where you’re glad to be able to stay indoors to shelter from the wind and rain.

Saturday night’s two Championship Series games were the perfect gift for anyone trying to find something to occupy the mind whilst huddled up away from the elements.

If you don’t have the time or inclination to re-watch the games in full then the Complete Game videos on MLB.com are a good way to catch up on the main flow of each game, even if the lack of commentary does take a bit of getting used to. Alternatively the Pulse of the Postseason video follows the timeline of the day in one neat 10 minute package.

First up on the ‘Pulse’ video is the St. Louis Cardinals’ 1-0 triumph over the Dodgers to take a 2-0 series lead as the teams head out to L.A.

Rookie Michael Wacha was impressive once again, but the most telling part of the tale came in Trevor Rosenthal’s 1-2-3 ninth inning to seal the Dodgers’ fate.

With Matt Kemp done for the season, Hanley Ramirez and Andre Ethier battling injuries and Yasiel Puig battling a loss of form, they are severely restricted when it comes to scoring runs and whilst pitching can take you a long way – good pitching beats good hitting, and so on – you can’t win if you can’t score runs.

Puig looked completely lost at the plate throughout the game and none more so than when he struck out to lead off the ninth inning, lumbering him with the ‘golden sombrero’ for four strikeouts. Juan Uribe, no one’s idea of a number 5 hitter on a World Series contender, then wildly hacked his way to the next strikeout, before Andre Either came off the bench to end the game striking out on three pitches.

L.A. have received two strong pitching performances from Zack Greinke and Clayton Kershaw and both have gone to waste due to their scuffling batting lineup. That lineup will now have to face the Cardinals’ best pitcher, Adam Wainwright, in Game Three whilst the Dodgers are likely to send Hyun-Jin Ryu to the mound knowing that he’s dealing with arm soreness and has been ineffective of late.

The Dodgers aren’t done just yet, but the Cardinals couldn’t be in a better position.

The other game of the night also finished 1-0 as Anibal Sanchez and the Detroit Tigers’ bullpen came within two outs of no-hitting what has been a potent Boston Red Sox batting lineup.

This series has been billed as a match-up between the Tigers’ starting pitching and the Red Sox’s offence and in that respect it was Detroit’s strength that won out in Game One. However, I suspect that it will be Detroit’s batting lineup that will determine the result of this series and in that sense the first game showed Boston how they could make it to another Fall Classic.

Even though they were handcuffed by the Tigers’ pitching – Boston fans have some reason to point to Joe West’s strikezone as a contributory factor too, although all hitters know they have to adjust to the zone being called on the night – they were always in the game because their own pitching was able to limit the Tigers’ offence.

Whilst Detroit are justified in having faith in their starting pitchers – not least in Max Scherzer for Game Two tonight – they’ll know that it’s unlikely they can win four games in this series against a strong Boston team if they can’t find a way to get the offence going around a clearly hobbled Miguel Cabrera.

You expect the Tigers to pitch well and, even in the face of this, you expect the Red Sox’s offence to score runs. What we should expect from the Tigers’ offence is less clear and finding out should make this a fascinating series.

Championship Series off to great start

The Los Angeles Dodgers and St. Louis Cardinals got the Championship Series stage of the 2013 postseason off to a flying start with an enthralling Game One on Friday night.

The Cards won 3-2 in thirteen innings and left U.K.-based fans wondering whether to go back to bed or just to get on with their Saturday morning with the game ending at close to 6.30 a.m. The latter was probably the option most took as it was difficult to drift off after such an exciting game.

Carlos Beltran once again proved to be an October hero, this time making two decisive plays to add to his postseason scrapbook.

The first came in the tenth inning when his perfect throw from the outfield beat a tagging-up Mark Ellis to home plate where Yadier Molina was more than happy to play the role of base-blocker to preserve the 2-2 scoreline. It looked initially from the TV footage that centre-fielder Jon Jay might take the fly-ball, but Beltran had the better angle to catch and fire and he did so brilliantly.

It was the second impressive outfield contribution to a double-play of the game after Dodgers right-fielder Yasiel Puig caught a David Freeze line drive and then smartly got the ball to first base to double-off Jay to end the seventh inning.

Beltran’s fielding play came with a side story, that of the man who hit the fly ball to him to start it off.

Adrian Gonzalez had walked to lead off the eighth inning and Dodgers manager Don Mattingly decided to take the first baseman out of the game for pinch-runner Dee Gordon. With all to play for in a 2-2 game, Mattingly’s keenness to take a late lead was understandable but it was a gamble considering Gordon still needed to get around from first base and, if he didn’t, the Dodgers would play the rest of the game without one of their most potent threats at the plate.

Unfortunately for LA, Mattingly’s gamble didn’t pay off – Gordon was out at second on a fielder’s choice in the next at-bat and Juan Uribe then grounded into a double-play to end the inning – and the result was that Michael Young took over Gonzalez’s spot in the batting lineup. It was Young who flied out tamely in the eleventh inning to set up Beltran’s double play and Young compounded the situation in the twelfth inning when he killed another Dodger rally by grounding into a double-play.

We’ll never know how the game might have panned out had Mattingly not been so hasty to remove one of his best hitters, but it certainly didn’t help their cause as the game ultimately unfolded and all Gonzalez could do was watch from the bench rather than stand in the batter’s box.

Gonzalez’s watching brief ended in the bottom of the thirteenth inning with the sight of Daniel Descalso crossing home plate to score the winning run. There was an air of expectation and also inevitability as Carlos Beltran stepped into the batter’s box with the game there to be won. Sure enough, he singled into the right field to send the Red Birds to a 1-0 series lead.

It was a great game and a great win for the Cardinals, not least because Zack Greinke was terrific on the mound for the Dodgers. Watching a masterful pitcher snapping off curveballs at will is one of the joys of baseball – unless you‘re the batter trying to hit them – and he struck out all three Cardinal batters with that pitch in the fifth on his way to ten K’s over eight innings.

Game Two of the series begins at 21.07 BST on Saturday and although it’s got a tough act to follow, don’t rule out it being just as exciting as the first with Clayton Kershaw and Michael Wacha on the mound.

Detroit and Boston will then get their series underway at 1.00 a.m. with Anibal Sanchez and Jon Lester taking to the mound at Fenway Park.

Weekly Hit Ground Ball: Teams on a charge

Now we’re firmly into August, there are a number of teams putting together some runs of form that are setting them up for a postseason berth.

The Atlanta Braves are the most prominent example. They came shooting out of the traps with a 17-9 record in April, new recruit Justin Upton leading the way by smashing the cover off the ball on a nightly basis. Upton then cooled off and the team kept up a steady if unspectacular pace, adding wins to their total without necessarily wowing anyone with their dominance.

Tim Hudson then suffered a gruesome fractured ankle on 24 July in a win against the New York Mets, putting the pitcher out for the rest of the season. Hudson had been struggling so losing him from the rotation wasn’t quite the blow you might initially expect, but he is a leader on the team and it could have had a wider negative effect. The Braves lost the next day against the Mets and everyone looked on wondering if a wobble was on the cards.

Not a bit of it; Atlanta reeled off a 14-game winning streak only ended on Saturday in a 1-0 loss to the Miami Marlins. Prior to Sunday’s games, they had a 14.5 game lead over the Washington Nationals in the NL East and the playoff odds on the ESPN.com standings had their chances of making it to the postseason at 99.9 per cent.

Three of those 14 wins came in a series sweep against the Nationals last week and Washington’s most notable contribution came via a bench-clearing incident when tensions boiled over after Bryce Harper was hit by a pitch.

The Braves’ good form has only served to heighten the sense of disappointment around the Nationals. After winning 98 games last year, they appeared to have a well-rounded roster set up to have a battle royal with the Braves all season long. Instead, they have fallen a long way short of expectations for a variety of reasons, in particular with off-season acquisitions Denard Span and Dan Haren playing poorly and the re-signed Adam LaRoche failing to repeat his success of 2012.

They’ve got enough talent and resources to get back into the race next season, but their handling of Stephen Strasburg’s innings last year looks worse by the day. If 2012 was their year, the Nationals failed to take advantage.

You could make the same argument about the Detroit Tigers, who played so well to get to the World Series only to end the season with a whimper by being swept in four-games by the San Francisco Giants (who themselves are having a very disappointing season, but that’s much easier to take when you have won two World Series recently).

The Tigers put together a 12-game wining streak recently, ended by the New York Yankees on Friday night, in a run that included a four-game sweep over the Indians in Cleveland. Whilst Terry Francona’s team are falling away, the Tigers are putting their foot down and their playoff odds (98.7%) were only marginally less impressive than the Braves before Sunday’s games.

Losing Jhonny Peralta to a 50-game suspension will have an impact because he had been arguably their second-best hitter so far this season behind the incredible Miguel Cabrera. However, General Manager Dave Dombrowski planned ahead by adding shortstop Jose Igelsias before the trade deadline and although he doesn’t figure to offer too much with the bat, his glovework will certainly improve what was a pretty dicey infield defence.

With Victor Martinez looking like he’s now knocked off the rust from missing all of 2012 with a knee injury, and a very impressive pitching staff even with Justin Verlander not performing quite at his best, Detroit look well set to make amends for their Fall Classic flop.

The recent form of the Tigers and Braves has helped cement their division leads, but the most impressive turnaround over the last month or so has come from a team that was dead-last in their division on 30 June. The Los Angeles Dodgers were 9.5 games out in the NL West on 22 June and although they had cut that to 4 by the team they had played their 81st game of the season on 30 June, they were still nowhere near where they should have been considering their sky-high payroll and array of talent.

Less than two months on, and a period of 28 wins from 35 games, the Dodgers sat atop the division with a 6.5 game lead before their series finale against the Rays on Sunday. What’s more, their 7-6 walk-off win against the Rays on Friday was one of those games that makes you think that destiny is on a team’s side.

L.A. were 6-0 down at the seventh-inning stretch and although they had cut the deficit in half by the time the bottom of the ninth came around, they still looked out of it with Fernando Rodney coming into the game and the 8, 9 and 1 hitter coming up to bat. Somehow the Dodgers rallied and when Rodney inadvertently chucked the ball into the outfield on an attempted force-out at second base, Adrian Gonzalez gleefully crossed home plate to seal one of the stranger walk-off wins you’ll see this season.

Manager Don Mattingly was able to ride out a rough spell earlier in the season when, considering the ‘win-now’ mentality that must exist in L.A. following their spending spree, it looked like he would be cast aside. He’s now leading a team that has every chance of making it to the playoffs.

Weekly Hit Ground Ball: Shouldering responsibility

The list of baseball incidents likely to catch the attention of the British press is a short one, topped by steroid scandals that over the past decade have sadly ‘won’ the sport a fair few column inches across the pond.

A 50-man plus, bench-clearing brawl is on that little list – who doesn’t enjoy seeing a good old dust-up? – and if you add in an injury to an expensively-acquired player an extra paragraph or two will be tacked on to the story.

As Carlos Quentin charged into Zack Greinke recently and everyone else began the familiar shoving match, the thought that came to mind was that it’s a wonder so few brawls (if we can really call them that) end up with an injury being suffered. In Greinke’s situation, you would not expect the player to come out from underneath the heap unscathed.

Against the odds, often a few bumps and bruises are the sum total of the damage done, but it wasn’t long after the bitter Dodgers-Padres clash ended that we found out Greinke had not been so lucky. Initial estimates propose that he will be out of action for at least eight weeks after undergoing surgery on his broken left collarbone.

Manager Don Mattingly’s emotional post-game opinion that Quentin should be banned for as long as the time Greinke has to miss was understandable, if never the least bit likely. When you invest $147m in a top-line pitcher, you’re going to be upset to see him injured in such a bizarre way.

Plenty of debate has been had about any intent on Greinke’s part with the high-and-inside pitch and Quentin’s decision to charge the mound, but in hindsight you would also have to question Greinke’s decision to meet Quentin by putting his shoulder into the well-built outfielder. It has shades of the macho stance that still leads some catchers to block the plate as a baserunner comes barrelling down the third-base line trying to smash him into next week.

That approach may please the masochists, but it isn’t clever to put yourself at such an extreme risk of injury that could cost your team dear. The smart catcher can skilfully tag the runner without putting himself in harm’s way. Greinke would have been wise – rather than a wimp – to have displayed a quick bit of footwork to sell Quentin the dummy before the cavalry came to smother out the danger.

Some may see it as a kill-joy, health-and-safety-gone-mad stance, but this isn’t rounding the edges off those dangerous pointy flapjacks. The Dodgers aren’t paying Greinke $147m to be a nightclub bouncer, they are paying him to pitch and he won’t be doing that for the next couple of months.

Replay the instant replay debate

The Premier League announced last week that they will be implementing HawkEye technology for goal line decisions from next season. MLB has apparently ruled out the use of such technology for fair/foul line calls, but it is expected that an increased use of instant replay will be adopted for the 2014 season.

The game-ending call between the Rays and Rangers last Monday raises an interesting question as to how that should be implemented.

At first glance, umpire Marty Foster’s decision to call the Rays’ Ben Zobrist out on strikes is exactly the sort of play that instant replay should be there for. It came at an important time (the final out of the game with the Rays trailing 4-3 with a runner on first) and was a clearly incorrect call. Nobody wants to see a blatant mistake by an umpire play a crucial part in the outcome of a game, especially the umpire that has to live with the mistake.

However, we don’t yet know whether an expanded instant replay referral system would include balls and strikes calls. My guess would be that the Umpires’ Union, and quite probably the MLB Commissioner’s Office too, would be dead-set against it.

The incorrect strike call on Zobrist was a freak event; most disputed calls on balls and strikes are more marginal. Most, if not probably all, cameras looking towards home plate do so at an angle that distorts the perception of the path of the pitch, so you couldn’t use the standard camera angles. That brings in the prospect of a PITCHf/x type tracking system being used and whilst some fans would be happy for computers to call all pitches, it’s safe to say the umpires would not agree.

As things currently stand, any new referral system would need to be introduced with the approval of the Umpires’ Union and opening the door to the use of a pitch-tracking system is likely to be refused.

It’s possible that the new system would give the umpires ultimate discretion to check any call and therefore a completely baffling error such as the one Foster made could be rechecked (i.e. with the umpire knowing that they had blown it and so referring it themselves), but don’t be surprised if the new system still results in such a call being met only with the consolation of an apology from the umpire.

Which for the team in question is no consolation at all.

Replay on Rajai

Another potential replay scenario cropped up during last week’s series between the Toronto Blue Jays and Detroit Tigers.

The Blue Jays’ speedster Rajai Davis attempted to steal second base and was called safe. On first viewing I thought the umpire had got the close call exactly right and I maintained that view having watched a replay. However, a second angle revealed that after narrowly beating the throw, Davis actually came off the bag briefly whilst Omar Infante kept the tag applied.

Infante didn’t make a big deal of it, but maybe he would have done had there been an option to refer the decision to a replay process.

Rule changes typically lead to changes in the way a game is played and the expanded use of instant replay will be no different. Every baserunner tries to stay on the bag when sliding in, just as every infielder knows they should keep the tag applied, but once instant replay comes into effect you should see players refining their technique.

The demand for additional replay has grown deafening as technological developments in TV coverage have hugely magnified the slightest error by an umpire. What shouldn’t be overlooked is that expanded replay will cast the same level of inspection on the players and slight mistakes that they presently get away with may come back to haunt them.