Home MLB MLB 2010 Predictions

MLB 2010 Predictions

by Matt Smith

MlbHlSqThe long offseason is almost over, teams only have a few Spring Training games left to play and many of the roster decisions have now been made.  The 2010 Major League season begins on Sunday (early hours of Monday for us in the UK) and it’s set to be another fantastic year of baseball.

So, it’s time to make some predictions.  As always, none of us really knows what is going to transpire over the next six months, which is precisely why it’s so much fun.  Five of us have picked out the division winners and wild cards from the regular season and then took a shot at how we think the postseason may unfold.  There’s a bit of personal bias in there, while Steve has decided to pick out the teams who have perhaps been undervalued by bookies and pundits alike.

Feel free to pass on your own predictions in the comments section below. 

American League

  East Central West Wild Card
Joe Yankees Twins Rangers Red Sox
Mark Yankees Twins Mariners Red Sox
Matt Yankees Twins Angels Red Sox
Russ Red Sox Twins Mariners Angels
Steve Red Sox White Sox Rangers Yankees


It’s difficult to see past the Yankees and Red Sox in the East and the loser of that personal battle is highly likely to take the consolation prize of the AL Wild Card.  That’s what conventional wisdom tells you and, aside from Russ tipping the Angels for the Wild Card, it’s a line of thinking followed by all of us. However what’s not picked up in the table above is that we don’t think it’s simply going to be a two-horse race.  Mark noted that the Tampa Bay Rays will finish “very close behind the Red Sox”, Steve has them down as “a reasonable outside chance” and I thought long and hard about putting them down for the Wild Card.  I do think they could do it, but the safer bet is on the two powerhouses coming through yet again. In particular, if the Rays have a disappointing first half to the season, they are much more likely to trade free-agents-to-be Carl Crawford and Carlos Pena rather than bring in reinforcements.

Both the Central and the West look like being very competitive divisions.  There’s a lot of optimism around the Twins and that’s reflected in our predictions, but the White Sox and Tigers should put them under pressure and Steve has Ozzie Guillen’s team edging it.  The West is arguably the most competitive division in the Majors simply because there is no clear-cut favourite, as reflected in our picks.  The A’s are the outsiders and would need everything to go their way to pip the others.  The Rangers and Mariners get two votes each, while I’m not quite ready to rule out the Angels.

Joe Red Sox over Twins, Yankees over Rangers Yankees over Red Sox
Mark Yankees over Twins, Red Sox over Mariners Yankees over Red Sox
Matt Yankees over Twins, Red Sox over Angels Red Sox over Yankees
Russ Red Sox over Angels, Twins over Mariners Twins over Red Sox
Steve Red Sox over White Sox, Rangers over Yankees Rangers over Red Sox


As for the postseason, all five of us have the Red Sox making the ALCS, which is perhaps at odds with some of the pessimism in Beantown due to the apparently lacklustre offence (it looks more than good enough to me).  Mark, Joe and I see a repeat of the 2003-2004 classics between the AL East rivals, while Russ and Steve are holding out hope for one of the so-called lesser teams getting the better of Boston and moving on to the Fall Classic.

National League

  East Central West Wild Card
Joe Braves Cardinals Dodgers Phillies
Mark Phillies Cardinals Rockies Dodgers
Matt Phillies Cardinals Rockies Braves
Russ Phillies Cubs Rockies Giants
Steve Braves Brewers Rockies Phillies


In the Senior Circuit, it’s no surprise that we all think the Phillies are going to make the postseason.  They’ve played in the last two World Series and they do not appear to be any weaker in 2010; however, both Joe and Steve see the Phils progressing to October via the Wild Card rather than a fourth straight NL East title.  The Atlanta Braves are tabbed as the team to break that sequence and their competitiveness is underlined by my selection of them as the Wild Card. 

The St. Louis Cardinals re-signed Matt Holliday over the offseason and with Albert Pujols hitting in front of him and two genuine aces in Chris Carpenter and Adam Wainwright at the front of their rotation, they have to be seen as the team to beat in the NL Central.  Even Steve noted that they are “the clear favourites”, but he countered that by stating that he thinks “it would be wrong t0 write off the Brewers” and that seems a fair shout.  Russ sees a rebound from the Cubs, while there was a certain amount of optimism among us for the Reds outside of the actual predictions for the division winner.  The fact that none of us see the Wild Card coming from the Central is an indication that it’s not likely to be the strongest division, although it may still be one of the most exciting if the Cardinals don’t fire on all cylinders and four teams enter the last month with a realistic shot at coming out on top.

The Rockies are the favourites to win the NL West for the first time in their relatively short history. Joe bucks the trend by backing the Dodgers, with Mark taking L.A. as his Wild Card pick and Russ putting faith in his Giants.  Mark isn’t quite so sure about that: “The Giants will be the best fourth-placed team in baseball [he has the D-Backs in 3rd] but a lack of offense will waste some excellent pitching from Lincecum and Cain”. 

Joe Cardinals over Phillies, Braves over Dodgers Cardinals over Braves
Mark Phillies over Dodgers, Cardinals over Rockies Phillies over Cardinals
Matt Phillies over Cardinals, Braves over Rockies Phillies over Braves
Russ Giants over Phillies, Rockies over Cubs Rockies over Giants
Steve Braves over Brewers, Phillies over Rockies Braves over Phillies


As with the AL postseason picks, the five of us have come up with four different World Series representatives.  Any of those potential NLCS match-ups would make for a great (and close) series.  The question then is whether the National League team will be strong enough to beat their American League opponent?

World Series

Joe Yankees over Cardinals
Mark Yankees over Phillies
Matt Red Sox over Phillies
Russ Twins over Rockies
Steve Rangers over Braves


Not by our reckoning: we’ve all got the AL team emerging triumphant.  Joe, Mark and I have gone down the conservative, and arguably the most probable, route with two votes for a Yankee repeat (Mark thinks the Phillies will stretch it to a 7 game series this time but with the same result as ‘09) and my selection of the Red Sox.  Russ sees the Twins following the Yankees’ ‘win it all with a new stadium’ approach and Steve goes out on a limb with the Rangers securing their first ever World Series title, “ruining the fairytale ending for Bobby Cox in five or six games”.

Not that Steve is overly confident with that prediction: “It´ll never happen, my head tells me one of Red Sox/ Yankees/ Phillies again, but I´m not tipping those sides. That would just encourage them”.  Joe took a similar line, signing off his predictions by stating “Obviously – I hope none of that happens!”. 

When it comes down to it, like everyone else we all want our own teams to do well, meaning the Mariners (Joe), Dodgers (Mark), A’s (me), Giants (Russ) and Mets (Steve).  In order of the most likely to do just that, I would go for Dodgers, Mariners, Giants, Mets, A’s, with the Dodgers being the only ones I would give a better than even chance of making the Championship Series.

We’ll revisit these predictions at the end of the season to see how they turned out.  What we can predict with all certainty is that it’s going to be another exciting season. 

Let us know who you think will triumph in 2010.

You may also like


peter March 30, 2010 - 7:46 pm

American League
East Central West Wild Card







National League
East Central West Wild Card







Matt Smith March 30, 2010 - 9:28 pm

Thanks for your predictions, Peter. No doubt the U.S. TV execs wouldn’t be so pleased, but I’d love to see a Braves-Twins World Series. What a way for Bobby Cox to sign off!

Joe Gray March 30, 2010 - 11:18 pm

Nice job on putting these together.

One further prediction, Ichiro will tie or beat DiMaggio’s 56-game hitting streak record.

Obviously, I know this is almost certainly not going to happen, but I do wonder how much less likely it would be than the .400+ season he’s been tipped for numerous times (it’s too late in the evening to start looking at the maths). (If it does happen I’ll come back in and delete this paragraph by [mis]using editor privileges and then look like a genius.)

Baseball’s Opening Day (with bonus MLB predictions) « Wait until next year April 4, 2010 - 7:07 pm

[…] put together some (vaguely) more coherent thoughts for the BaseballGB site’s MLB predictions post, but you lucky readers, I thought I’d give you the full version of my ramblings here. Think […]


Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.