Tag Archives: Prospects

Prospects looking good

We’re at the point in the off-season when all the major signings have been completed and yet we’re still a few weeks away from players reporting to their respective Spring Training camps.

That makes it a good time to check up on some of the best young players in the Minor Leagues.

MLB.com only paid a passing interest in prospects until a few years ago when Jonathan Mayo was joined by Jim Callis on the site and they started to make a feature of the MLBPipeline section.

They’ve just announced their latest prospect rankings, listing the top 100 young players still with rookie eligibility alongside other breakdowns such as the top 10 prospects at every position and top 30 rankings for every team (the latter to be published soon).

There’s lots of great information to learn from and it’s really well presented, so it’s an excellent resource to tap into. The only minor criticism I have is that they don’t state the level of play in the stat lines for the players (you have to know which league the abbreviation refers to and what level of play that is, High-A, Double-A etc), which would be helpful to have at a glance rather than needing to read through the player comments in full first up every time.

There are other great sources of information out there (the prospect coverage on BaseballProspectus – subscription usually required for the prospect articles - and Fangraphs, MinorLeagueBall.com, Keith Law’s Insider work on ESPN.com – again requiring a subscription etc), but MLBPipeline is by far the most accessible and user-friendly prospect resource and is the place I’d recommend all baseball fans start at when wanting to learn about the young players in the Minor Leagues.

Here are a few initial thoughts from the top 100 rankings.

Those with the biggest pockets still value prospects

The Los Angeles Dodgers have had a strange off-season, but the fact that they have two of the top four prospects (Corey Seager at #1, Julio Urias at #4) is instructive on why they have tended to spend their money on shorter ‘win now’ deals rather than longer-term commitments this winter.

The ‘luxury tax’ on high-revenue teams means that it still makes sense to develop a core group of talented ‘homegrown’ players and then use their financial clout to add extra specific pieces to the puzzle and to sign the young players to contract extensions a few years down the line. We’ve seen Boston take that approach with prospect graduates Xander Bogaerts and Mookie Betts and the New York Yankees’ out-of-character shyness on the free agency market this off-season is also part of a plan for them to get younger over the next year or so and then spend money on free agents in future.

Texas keep on producing prospects 

The Texas Rangers have had one of the most celebrated farm systems over the past five years or so and their ability to keep re-stocking their ranks from the draft, international signings and picking up prospects from other teams is impressive.

The likes of Rougned Odor and Delino Deshields Jr (the latter picked up from Houston a year ago) played key roles in the Rangers’ charge to the AL West title in 2015, as did the trade for ace pitcher Cole Hamels that was made possible by them having a deep system from which to trade from.

The Rangers have five players in the MLBPipeline top 100 and they ranked top in the ‘Prospect Point’ list, all despite trading away three top 100 prospects to get Hamels.

Phillies rebuild taking shape

The Philadelphia Phillies finally bit the bullet and started a rebuild and that’s given them more prospects in the top 100 (7) than any other team, three of which were the players acquired in the Hamels trade.

The Major League team might not be much fun in the present, but the future does now look bright after a couple of years of directionless dithering.

The next golden era of shortstops?

The Houston Astros’ Carlos Correa and the Cleveland Indians’ Francisco Lindor both took to the Major League with aplomb in 2015 and immediately became two of the best shortstops around.

MLBPipeline’s number one prospect Corey Seager also impressed after making his debut in September for the Dodgers, especially when it came to his fielding. He’s one of six potential shortstops in their top 12 and, as with several of the others, questions remain as to whether he will remain at that position or move to third base.

Seager showed enough promise during his initial Major League appearances to suggest he can stick at the position for a while yet, and if so then we could be witnessing the next great shortstop era since the Derek Jeter, Alex Rodriguez and Nomar Garciaparra era of the early 2000’s.

Max Kepler – flying the European flag

Finally, we can’t overlook the one European player on the list. Kepler comes in at number 44 and he made his Major League debut on 27 September last year for the Minnesota Twins.

The German has been pegged as the best European prospect in years since signing a $800k bonus with the Twins back in 2009 and slowly but surely he has developed his game while climbing up the Minor League levels.

Kepler turns 23 on 10 February and hopefully he will keep improving and earn a regular spot on the Twins’ Major League roster as the 2016 season progresses.

Prospects are good

MLB.com published their Top 100 prospect list on Tuesday evening.

As expected, the Texas Rangers’ shortstop prospect Jurickson Profar was listed as the best rookie-eligible player in the game.  The Baltimore Orioles’ Dylan Bundy came in second and won the crown as the best pitching prospect.

There is plenty of Major League news to keep up with, especially when factoring in the time difference. Covering all the Minor League news as well can often be a time commitment too far and the wealth of online resources about prospects, whilst being a goldmine to those with a keen interest in the topic, can only serve to overwhelm the rest of us.

What I want to know about prospects is essentially:

  • Who are the best prospects in baseball?
  • Who are the main prospects at each team that I should know about?
  • How do the different farm systems rank against each other?

MLB.com’s prospect coverage is led by writer Jonathan Mayo and is an excellent free resource for fans to learn about the above. The Top 100 list announced yesterday was preceded by a series of columns listing Mayo’s rankings of the top 10 prospects at each position and all of the rankings are now available to sort however you wish.

The videos included for the best prospects can also be useful in helping you learn the pronunciation of the names.  You don’t pronounce the ‘l’s in the Pittsburgh Pirates’ right-handed pitching prospect  Jameson Taillon’s name (it’s pronounced ‘tie-on’), for example.

Away from the MLB.com coverage, the free resource I browse the most is the MinorLeageBall blog run by John Sickels. His team-by-team Top 20 prospect series is essential reading every winter, whether you’re participating in a Fantasy Dynasty League or if you just have a general interest in learning about each team’s best young players coming through.

The player rankings constructed in the team-by-team series informs Sickel’s annual Baseball Prospect Book, available in print or as a pdf. If you enjoy his work for free during the season, buying the annual is the best way to show your appreciation.

The one thing Sickels didn’t do prior to 2012 is help with the third question on my list. Ranking the farm systems is something he had consciously avoided in the past, primarily because he saw the process as being relatively unhelpful beyond the extremes of noting the very best and worst systems.

Sickels finally gave in to the demand last year and now publishes a farm system list accompanied by suitable caveats to explain the inherent limitations in the process.  Fans of the St. Louis Cardinals will be pleased to see their team coming out on top, whilst fans of the Detroit Tigers should make sure to enjoy their current Major League team with limited help on the way.

That shouldn’t be too much of a concern for the Tigers because having a strong farm system is a means to an end, not an end in itself.

After seeing the Cardinals at the top of Sickels’ list, the next thing I did was scroll down to see where my Oakland A’s had ended up. They are all the way down at 26th on the list, but their descent from 10th in the 2012 list is predominantly due to prospects graduating up to the Major League team last season, which is exactly what you want to see.

The same could be said for the Toronto Blue Jays. They were the best farm system on Sickels’ list this time last year and are now 22nd; however this is due to them trading away prospects to acquire the likes of Jose Reyes, Josh Johnson, Mark Buehrle and R.A. Dickey this offseason.  The Blue Jays feel they have an opportunity to be successful over the next couple of seasons and they’ve used their prospects to give themselves that chance.

If you want to know who to look out for during Spring Training, who might get called up this season or who might be traded away for Major League help, reading Mayo and Sickels is a must.